To learn more about Book Spotlight, read this.
Shadow Life, written by Hiromi Goto and illustrated by Ann Xu, chronicles the ups and downs of old age in snapshots from the life of senior Kumiko Saito.
What I liked:
- I’ve worked with seniors and I’ve witnessed how dementia, Alzheimer’s, and other diseases drastically affect a person’s day-to-day experiences. Although Kumiko does not appear to have dementia or Alzheimer’s, her disorientation, forgetfulness, and quickness to question her grasp of reality felt incredibly true to life. Her thought processes, particularly the scenes where she secures the vacuum cleaner after trapping Death, encourage empathy rather than contempt, as if Goto is inviting the reader to step into the shoes of senior life as opposed to looking in from the outside.
- Normally, I skim past the author’s note, but Goto’s note is both informative and deeply personal. I appreciate all the topics she touches on, including being inspired by her grandmother and wanting to see and create more nuanced media depictions of older BIPOC women.
- Xu’s illustrations felt perfect for the story. Her use of facial expressions, gestures, and poses to evoke particular moods in each scene was especially effective at capturing the mix of loneliness, nostalgia, anxiety, pain, and love which seemingly form major components of Kumiko’s life.
- Speaking of loneliness, Goto astutely depicts the effects of loneliness and isolation on seniors’ lives. In Kumiko’s case, while she is strong and independent in many ways, and revels in the freedom of setting up her life outside the retirement home, we also see her at moments of intense vulnerability, when she is hit with the realization she cannot manage everything on her own. I think especially of scenes such as her fall on the sidewalk and subsequent rescue by Meena, her growing fear and confusion in her apartment when she cannot remember if she took her medication, and her imprisonment in Death’s cocoon. Throughout her ordeals, Kumiko steadfastly refuses to call upon her daughters for help. There are many reasons seniors refuse to ask their families for help, including fear of losing control of their lives (like Kumiko) or not wanting to be a burden. Sadly, there are also instances when family members are unwilling or unable to provide support to their senior relatives.
What I learned:
- I need to read more about Japanese Canadian experiences during the war. Although it felt perfectly logical for Kumiko to oppose Alice’s enlistment, which calls to mind the no-no boys among US nikkei, Kumiko and Alice’s relationship made me realize I know next to nothing about Japanese Canadian history, other than a vague feeling of it being similar to US nikkei history.
Questions I had:
- How do bi and/or gay nikkei readers feel about the portrayal of Kumiko and Alice’s relationships, as well as each character individually? How might Goto’s work be situated within the existing body of works by nikkei writers in the LGBTQIA+ community? Specifically, are there major generational differences in how bi and/or gay nikkei readers view Kumiko and Alice?
- Is there a Japanese edition of Shadow Life? Kumiko occasionally utters exclamations or phrases in Japanese, which, juxtaposed with her primarily English dialogue, helps to frame her identity as a multilingual nikkei senior. I’m curious about how these moments would be handled by a translator, since simply changing the entire line to Japanese would erase what I consider a rather key component of nikkei identity.
Follow-up:
- I believe I have several of Goto’s books in my TBR, so I’ll have to dig those up and take a look.
You must be logged in to post a comment.